Nights of Eternity Tier List

This hub is the September 2026 public-lobby ranking for Nights of Eternity on Roblox. It is built for solo queue and mixed pubs, not for a coordinated five-stack that voice-calls every arcade. ST-GB Team’s night is online 1-versus-all: survivors clear cabinets and live until the timer, one animatronic hunts a server of up to nine. Power is not “who has the scariest model.” Power is who still has a button in Last Man Standing when the clock jumps to 1:14 and both auras light up.

Split pages live here:

• Survivor tier list — Phone Guy and Cassidy in S, Night Guard and Henry in A, Evan in B, Michael in C. Charlie Emily is early access and not firmly ranked.
• Killer tier list — Withered Bonnie and Springtrap in S, Foxy in A, Freddy in B.

Kit pages for the names that already have them: Phone Guy, Cassidy, Night Guard, Springtrap, Withered Bonnie. Full roster context sits on the players hub.

How we rank pubs

S means you can carry a noisy lobby. A means you are good if you hit your buttons. B means the kit works and still dies to a focused killer. C means you are fighting the kit as much as the animatronic. We are not inventing a D tier to be dramatic. Michael sits in C because shockers underperform, not because the character is unplayable.

Sources are community match videos and the way pubs actually queue after the Cassidy drop and Withered Bonnie early access. This is not a tournament seed. If your five-stack always saves with Evan, your table can disagree with ours. Solo queue cannot assume that save.

Survivor snapshot

S — Phone Guy, Cassidy (early access). Phone Guy’s shock-wave stun is short, readable, and stacks health on successful hits, so a sentinel who lands two stuns becomes a thicker loop. Cassidy brings torment (slow plus resistance while she holds the killer’s attention), a self-heal, and a rift for reposition. In pubs that refuse to stun, she still has a selfish win condition.

A — Night Guard, Henry. Night Guard is the free survivalist: mask and pizza tools that are honest if you time them. Henry’s corner strike is one of the best sentinels in a coordinated hallway and one of the most wasted kits when teammates never bait through a wall.

B — Evan. Support that can keep a night alive and still folds if the killer looks at him twice. Pick him when the lobby already has a stun, not as your first solo queue lock. The survivor picker spells that out.

C — Michael. Information and shockers. The info is real; the damage and control are not enough for the time he spends lining them up. He needs a buff or a very patient lobby.

Unranked — Charlie Emily. Early-access survivor. Too few public games to freeze a letter. See the roadmap rather than a fake S.

Killer snapshot

S — Withered Bonnie (early access), Springtrap. Bonnie’s grab punishes heals and turns support nights into a coin flip. Springtrap is the complete free kit: pressure, tools, and a game plan that works on every current map. If you can only learn one killer, learn him.

A — Foxy. Sneak and commit. He eats isolated arcade runners and loses when the lobby clumps with Phone Guy stun duty.

B — Freddy. Zone and setup. Strong if survivors walk into the plan, slow if they do not. Pubs that scatter cabinets will make him look worse than he is; pubs that all sit one cluster will make him look like S for a round.

Puppet is a future killer on the roadmap, not a ranked row. Vanessa was scrapped and is not hiding in the shop.

What this hub is not

It is not a skin tier list. Cosmetics on Cassidy or Bonnie videos do not change roman-numeral status effects. It is not a “pay to win” chart. Tokens buy access; they do not rewrite stun duration. It is not frozen. When Charlie’s kit has a public sample, the survivor page will move first.

If you are new, ignore the letters for one night. Queue Night Guard or Phone Guy, finish getting started, and then come back. The ranking is for people who already know why Last Man Standing deletes Undetectable.